We are digital piano & keyboard specialists, based in Banbury, Oxfordshire. Stay up to date with the latest news, reviews, tips, and offers by joining our FREE newsletter (unsubscribe at any time).
Here’s my comparison of two brilliant portable pianos: It’s the Yamaha P-S500 vs P-515.
Below, I’ll explain the main differences between these two models which are often compared because they’re in the same range and in a similar price bracket.

At first glance, they look quite similar, and there are many similarities. For example, they both have the standard amount of keys for a piano: 88.
Plus, the keys themselves are ‘weighted’ – meaning that they feel very similar to a traditional piano to play.
Looking at the chassis, they’re both obviously designed to be relatively portable. They’re narrow and fairly compact. Neither is supplied with a stand in the box, but are flat underneath – meaning you can put them on a tabletop or a fold-up portable stand, etc.
This blog is all about the differences between these two models. Hopefully, it’ll help you decide which one is right for you.

36m
Chris explains the main differences between the Yamaha P-S500 & P-515 portable pianos
The major difference that stands out to me is that the Yamaha P-S500 has an integrated, visual learning system called Stream Lights and is very much designed to assist people who are either complete beginners or that prefer learning in a visual way, perhaps because they don’t get along with traditional learning methods like reading music.
The Stream Lights learning system uses lights that appear on a panel above the keys. They ‘fall’ down towards the keys showing you which notes to play, and crucially, which notes to play next for your selected song.
This system is extremely easy to use. Even complete beginners are able to sit down at this piano, follow the Stream Lights to learn music, and play along with the backing songs.
The Yamaha P-515 does not include the integrated Stream Lights learning system.

The Yamaha P-515 has a superior weighted key mechanism. This means that playing it is a more authentic representation of playing a traditional piano than playing the P-S500.
While both models do have weighted keys, the P-515 uses a more advanced mechanism called NWX (Natural Wood X). The white keys are actually wooden – just like on a traditional piano – which makes them more authentic to play.
Speaking of being authentic to play, the X part of NWX action indicates that there is a simulated escapement mechanism included too.
On traditional pianos, the escapement is what allows the hammer to be released from the string after striking it – even when the key is still depressed, allowing the string to continue vibrtating.
There are no strings in a digital piano, of course, however, the feeling of the escapement mechanism (which feels like a little bump at the end of the key travel) is not insignificant on traditional pianos, and the inclusion of it on the P-515, as well as the synthetic ebony and ivory keytops, indicates the level of detail that Yamaha go into to recreate the real experience of playing a traditional piano.

In comparison, the Yamaha P-S500, while it does have ‘weighted keys’, uses an inferior mechanism called GHS (Graded Hammer Standard).
While this system is perfectly adequate for beginners, and even intermediate-level players, it’s, without a doubt, an area where the P-S500 is inferior to the P-515. The GHS key mechanism is the same as can be found on the student-level Yamaha P45 model.
If you play the piano to a high standard, I’m almost certain that you’ll be able to feel instantly how the wooden keys on the P-515 allow your fingers to move more nimbly over the keyboard – particularly when playing fast passages.
This is an area where there’s significant divergence in what these two pianos offer, and there’s no doubt whatsoever that the P-S500 offers far more than the P-515.
The P-515 will give you x40 ‘Rhythms’ of various different musical genres, but they’re so basic that I only really consider them good for practice purposes. They’re a little like glorified metronomes.
They give you a simple drum beat backing and a very basic Bass Guitar which follows your chord inputs on the keyboard. There are no proper introductions, variations, drum fills, or endings, so you can’t really put together anything like a polished live performance.
In comparison, the Rhythms & Accompaniments on the P-S500 are just miles, and miles better. And, when you’ve got the companion app connected (more on this next), you have more than x600 to play with!
Not only do you have hundreds of different music styles and genres to choose from, but the backings themselves contain multiple instruments and patterns making it genuinely sound like you’re performing as part of a complete band or orchestra.
There are multiple variations within the Styles too that help you build up the intensity of a song through verses, middle 8s, and choruses. Plus, you’re able to use pro-sounding introductions and ending to put together polished performances.
If you’re familiar with the Yamaha CVP, Tyros/Genos, and PSR models, you’ll understand the depth of variation that I’m referring to on these types of backing accompaniments.

Yamaha’s superb Smart Pianist app is designed to work with many of their digital pianos and is compatible with both the P-515 and P-S500.
However, aside from the basic functionality of controlling the Voices, there’s a significant difference in what the app brings to each of these models.
When using the Smart Pianist app with the Yamaha P-515, the app only shows you what’s already available on the piano. For example, you can change the onboard voices, layer the onboard voices, select an onboard rhythm, change the tempo, etc.
It acts like a portal to what’s already built into the P-515.
When using the Smart Pianist app with the Yamaha P-S500, you actually unlock loads of extra Voices, backing Styles, Songs, recording functionality, and more. Only a tiny fraction of which would be available if you were using the piano as a stand-alone model.
Here’s an example of what I mean:
As you can see, while the P-S500 can be used without a smart device, it really should be used with one. In my opinion, it’s practically essential because it brings you much more than simply using the P-S500 as a stand-alone piano.
See my full P-S500 video review below for more details on what the Yamaha Smart Pianist app can do.
10m
Chris reviews & demonstrates the Yamaha P-S500 Smart Piano.
Both of these pianos use the same main piano sample from Yamaha’s world-renowned CFX Concert Grand Piano. They also both contain the beautiful Bosendorfer Imperial Grand.
Spec-wise, there’s nothing significant between them, however, I want to give you my opinion of the playing experience.
I’ll get straight to it: For someone with my playing experience (25 years+), I think the Yamaha P-515 is superior.
Why? Because it feels to me like a more natural playing experience. Firstly, the touch (with the wooden keys) instantly feels ‘right’ when I lay my hands on it, and encourages a more natural flow in my playing.
Consequently, the way I attack the notes changes in response. I’m inputting more nuance in my keystrokes because the keyboard and speakers seem to respond to it. It feels more attuned to my playing standard and style.

Playing the P-S500 is not the same experience. Bare in mind that I’m someone who has played many different models of digital piano and keyboard over my 15+ years in the industry – so I’ve become ultra-choosy!
I do think, however, that to a beginner, the difference is not going to be instantly noticeable.
The P-S500 does have a good weighted key mechanism, it feels realistic, and, if I was teaching a beginner and they said they were practicing on this model between lessons, I’d be quite happy!
However, in comparison to the P-515, I find the P-S500 a little stiff and one-dimensional to play. The plastic keys don’t respond to the variation of my inputs with the same agility as the P-515’s wooden keys.
It’s shouldn’t be a deal-breaker, but as I’m comparing the two, I want to be as honest as I can, and that’s just how I feel about them!

What becomes obvious in this comparison is that these two models are simply designed for different purposes. There’s a lot of crossover in the basics of what they offer – they’re both pianos after all!
However, I think a fair conclusion would be that the Yamaha P-S500 is designed to aid people that are learning to play, and who like using technology like backing accompaniments, and smart devices.
In comparison, the Yamaha P-515 is designed to offer a premium-level playing experience and to facilitate the greater requirements – the sensitivities, articulation, and subtleties – of a higher standard of playing.
[relatedblogs]
Comments:
Thanks for this great comparison! Much appreciated.
January 13th., 2024
“e P”
Sir: “Chris Hammon”:
Receive you, a warm greeting, and all my thanks for the interesting and important INFORMATION that you have
been able to provide about the -Differences- between the “YAMAHA” Piano Model P-S500 and the Piano Model P-
525.
It has been all a great information that I have learned, according to your explanation; and that will help me to know
which of the -Two Pianos- is the one that I really need. And where you have been able to SPECIFY with much
ACCURACY and PROFESSIONALISM, according to your “EXPERIENCE”.
Thank you once again for your service to the community of those interested in learning about Modern Digital
Pianos!
From you, with all respect and admiration
Mr. “Hannibal Selas”